thoughts on the Mariners, MLB draft, and more home • links • draft • about me
Showing posts with label Justin Ruggiano. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Justin Ruggiano. Show all posts

No Z In Defense

Happy trails, Justin Ruggiano. We hardly knew ye.
(Source: Wikimedia, uploaded by user UCinternational)
Yesterday's Mark Trumbo trade left a hole at backup catcher, which today was filled by recalling Jesus Sucre from AAA Tacoma. This is not surprising. More surprising is that Sucre took Justin Ruggiano's spot. Ruggiano was designated for assignment to make room.

Ruggiano was essentially a fourth outfielder - technically a platoon partner for Seth Smith, but as the righty in the platoon he would face lefties. That means less playing time. He accumulated 81 at-bats across 36 games so far this season, and produced 0.1 WAR according to Fangraphs. Ruggiano, for all intents and purposes, was a replacement level bench player for the Mariners this year. So, it is hard to get all that angry over the move today.

With that said, the move suggests a fatal flaw in the logic of Lloyd McClendon and Jack Zduriencik. The Mariners are down to two legitimate outfield defenders on the roster (Austin Jackson and Dustin Ackley). That's concerning when you have three outfield positions to fill. 

It is particularly remarkable that Ruggiano got cut loose instead of Rickie Weeks, given that Ruggiano has outperformed Weeks so far this year and also has a skillset that is a better fit for the current M's roster. I think Weeks is a better hitter than he has shown so far, and also has some upside defensively as he learns the outfield, but why try to coach one player up when another already fits the roster spot better? The Mariners fancy themselves a contender, and contenders tend to think about winning ballgames sooner rather than later.

I will be surprised if the Mariners make the playoffs at this point. The Ruggiano DFAing put me over the top. Jack Zduriencik and company may very well continue to acquire talent, but the M's are ripping open wounds to fix non-existent problems. The Mariners do not need more dingers. They need men on base and an outfield that allows pitchers to take advantage of spacious Safeco Field. They are hacking away from these weaknesses to add home runs at the moment.

It is one thing to get frustrated when a player like Robinson Cano doesn't perform well. It is another thing to watch a team take a flawed approach to building a roster, amplify the problems, and then wonder why they aren't winning more ballgames. The Mariners are going to have to outpace their own decision-makers to make playoffs, which is a mighty tall order.

Ruggiano Acquired, Seth Smith Watch Begins

proof that Seth Smith plays the outfield
(Julio Enriquez, Flickr via Wikemedia Commons)
The Mariners made a small move today that they tried to play as a big one by sending out a bulk e-mail about it to fans. They acquired OF Justin Ruggiano from the Cubs for minor league pitcher Matt Brazis.

Let's start with Brazis. He is a 25-year-old righty bullpen arm that put up some great numbers split between High Desert and Jackson. However, he is already a bullpen arm, and a bit old for the leagues he was playing in. He could prove to be replacement level bullpen arm in the majors, but it's doubtful he turns into much more. The Mariners farm system remains in tact.

Then again, the Mariners didn't acquire an incredible talent either, though Ruggiano brings some needed skills. Ruggiano, now 32 years old, broke through a few seasons ago with a surprising second-half surge in Miami. He has never duplicated that magical half-season, but he continues to flash a surprising power-speed combo with limited contact and on-base skills. He combines that with an adequate outfield glove that's even capable of playing in center field. Basically, Ruggiano is a poor team's version of Michael Saunders - or, perhaps a mirror image of Saunders. Ruggiano bats right-handed, seemingly a requirement for the Mariners to pursue a batter these days.

Justin Ruggiano is not an everyday player for a contending team, though his skillset would be very nice to have on the bench. With that said, finding Ruggiano a platoon partner could work out nicely. His wRC+ for his career against lefties is 128, while against righties it is 94. If you aren't familiar with wRC+, a score of 100 is league average. Ruggiano doesn't have a massive split, and he's not a black hole against righties, but he's clearly better against lefties. Moreover, he's better enough, and in the right talent range, that the little edge is the difference between a bench player and a bona fide starter.

So, it would make good sense for the Mariners to find another corner outfielder with a complimentary split. Enter Seth Smith of the San Diego Padres, who I will admit I have been a longtime fan of. I love his swing and overall offensive game. It should play nicely in Safeco Field. Smith, for his career, has a 123 wRC+ against righties and a suicidal 63 wRC+ against lefties. That is a truly massive platoon split, and it's so crippling (given Smith's below-average defense) that it pretty much makes Smith a role player.

Smith, by the way, should be available in the very near future. The Padres have rumored deals complete for Matt Kemp and Wil Myers, both corner outfielders at this point. There would be no logical place for Smith to play, and given his non-prospect status without a role on the Padres, he should not cost the M's a top prospect.

If the Mariners acquired Smith and paired him intelligently with Ruggiano, they are looking at slightly below average defense with a 120 wRC+ in right field. For comparison, Saunders posted a 126 wRC+ last season with above average defense. Saunders is still the better option, but at least at the dish he would not be missed too badly in this scenario.

So let the Seth Smith watch begin, because at this point he's the guy that makes both the Saunders and Ruggiano trades make sense. I still despise the Saunders-Happ trade, but I would tip my cap to Zduriencik if he finds a way to string together a decent everyday right-fielder out of non-premium prospects.